Barbarian Rugby Cardigan

I'm 5'10", appx. 215 lbs. In most retail men's sizes, I'm somewhere between a large and an XL. I bought these cardigans in XL, believing that I could possibly shrink them a bit if they were too large. But XL fit very tight (Canadian sizes?). I returned them a couple days after receiving them, and got an email from Rugby Imports that they were sending me out XXL's. I think the cardigans look sharp, and Rugby Imports was very accommodating with the return; the sizing was certainly not the fault of Rugby Imports.